Skip to Content

Close Reading: Asking Thick & Thin Questions

This free focus on close reading resource helps you teach students how to differentiate and form thick and thin questions.

Close Reading: Asking Thick and Thin Questions from The Curriculum Corner

This is another free resource for teachers from The Curriculum Corner.

This asking thick and thin questions collection is a part of our series on Close Reading.  If you are looking for additional free resources, please visit our Complete Close Reading Collection.

As you work to incorporate the skill of Close Reading into your daily classroom routine, you will find our set of free Close Reading materials a helpful tool.

How will these resources help you teach close reading?

This specific post focuses on the skill of teaching students to differentiate between thick and thin questions.

They will learn about the difference.

They will be encouraged to develop their own questions to fit within these two categories.

Thick & Thin Questions

The goal of these printables is to help children begin to learn how to differentiate between thick and thin questions. Students will then learn how to ask deeper questions.

How do thick & thin questions help with self-monitoring during reading?

An important part of self-monitoring is asking questions while reading.

Often, it can be difficult for students to determine how to ask meaningful questions.

We like to help students understand how questions can differ by referring to them as thick or thin questions.  

Once students understand the difference, they can be encouraged to form questions that dig deeper into the text.

asking thick and thin questions

What You Will Find

  • Anchor Chart – We have provided this anchor chart in color and in black and white.
  • Mini Anchor Charts – These can be placed at a center for a reference or glued into interactive reading notebooks. Again, we are providing these anchor charts in color as well as in black and white.
  • Thick or Thin Card Sort –  These cards can have a variety of uses in your room.  You may choose to begin by using it during a mini-lesson and ask the class to work together to sort each question into the correct category.  The cards could also be used as prompts for students developing their own questions.  Or, the cards could be used during a literacy club as a way to guide questioning.
  • Thick or Thin Questions Practice Page – Before students can be expected to ask questions in their head to self-monitor while reading, they must be given many opportunities to practice this skill.
    • We have created this graphic organizer as an exit slip to be used in your classroom.
    • We suggest first modeling during a mini-lesson.  The next day we would repeat the activity while asking students to have more input in the formation of questions.
    • When students are ready, assign this page as a task during independent reading, reviewing answers during group share time at the end of class.
    • For readers who are still struggling with this task, you might use this to guide your small group reading instruction.   Laura over at ReadLearnTeachLife suggests using the book Westlandia for practicing the skill of developing thick and thin questions.  We checked it out and think it is a great fit for the lesson.  If you have another favorite, please share below
  • Thick or Thin Questions Bookmark Exit Tickets – Use these when you want to do a quick check.  Students are asked to record one thick and one thin question.

You can download this free set here:

Thick & Thin Close Reading

There are so many ideas out there for teaching this concept.  What about using the game Headbanz to give students practice?  

We also found a picture of a class activity where a teacher had students record thick questions on regular size post-it notes and thin questions on the mini post-it tabs.  What a great visual!  Do you have other ideas?  We would love to hear them!

Here are a few resources that might help you with your focus on Thick & Thin Questions (contains affiliate links)


As with all of our resources, The Curriculum Corner creates these for free classroom use. Our products may not be sold. You may print and copy for your personal classroom use. These are also great for home school families!

You may not modify and resell in any form. Please let us know if you have any questions.

Edie

Friday 16th of April 2021

Thank you for this awesome resource!

Little Dreamers: Visionary Women Around the World - The Curriculum Corner 4-5-6

Tuesday 19th of November 2019

[…] a “thinking deeper” question with the prompting of a card. (Check out our post on Thick or Thin Questions to help your students learn this task. Once a student has formed a question, the remainder of the […]

Just Google It – Wiley Wonders

Monday 4th of June 2018

[…] think of these types of questions as lower level questions that have an easy answer.  According to The Curriculum Corner these lower level questions can be thought of as thin questions and higher level questions can be […]

Close Reading Collection - The Curriculum Corner 4-5-6

Monday 22nd of May 2017

[…] Asking Thick & Thin Questions […]

Blanca

Thursday 5th of November 2015

Thanks, this really helps students to understand the difference between simple and complex questions. Good idea.